What a fantastic read! I finished the book in 4 days while on holiday, I just couldn’t put it down. I’m still telling people about this 6 months after reading it. If you are looking for your next book do it buy flawed, then perfect. You won’t regret it! Fantastic author I have read almost all of your books, never stop writing. Your amazing!

Fast paced, edge of your seat, easy read. Might’ve been written for young adults, but this is one for all. Was desperate to read the follow on book

I’m enjoying this book thoroughly and think it has a clever outlook on a futuristic turn out. Although I don’t usually enjoy books like these it changed my idea of these book and now I enjoy them

Could not put this book down, read it as though I was writing it.

Enjoyed this book, until it came to the end, because the story didn't finish. The cost of the sequel to this book is £7.99, and I didn't enjoy it enough to pay that.

This had me on the edge of my seat, could not put it down. I can't wait for the next instalment!

I definitely recommend reading this book to anyone that hasn't already. With a plot line that kept me guessing, wondering what choices would be made, this book kept me on my toes. There is some graphic and violent description, however nothing too extreme. Celestine is a character that I cannot wait to read more of, and I hope to see the next book soon.

I enjoyed this far more than the marble collector. I know it is for young adults but I thought the moral of the tale was excellent for up and coming young people who need to think about compassion instead of "rules". I have read all of Celia Ahern's books and this has the key elements that I enjoy.

Wow. My first Cecelia Ahern read, and most definitely not my last! Absolutely loved this book, loved the story, the writing style and the characters. I really connected with Celestine, more so towards the end of the book, but yes, I think she makes an excellent heroine, I loved the way her mind works. A perfect girl living in a perfect city, a city that does not accept flaws, Celestine finally realises the city is far from perfect. Once she had made this decision I loved seeing her character develop. This is an emotional rollercoaster ride from start to finish, we have the perfect villain in Crevan, and the perfect sidekicks in Art and Juniper. This book is not for the faint hearted, some scenes were quite upsetting and quite graphic. There is of course the love interest, Carrick, even though I know Art is supposed to be Celestine's girlfriend, we all know Carrick is going to be 'the one' (he better be). I am so looking forward to reading the next instalment, there better be one! I received an ARC of this book from the publisher in exchange for an unbiased review.