What's the Big Idea? Finally, Sarah Vine (once memorably described as being ‘like and loathed in equal measure, divisive, but never indecisive’) and Peter Hitchens (a man whose writing a critic was called to compare to a Guardsman’s boot: ‘as highly polished and potentially lethal’) meet once a week to look at the world and mutter, alas… Acclaimed columnist and journalist Sarah Vine and best-selling author and broadcaster Peter Hitchens discuss and dissect social, economic, and pop cultural flotsam and jetsam that have risen out of the dark waters of that week’s news.
Taking one big idea each episode and pulling it apart with élan, imagine Vine and Hitchens respective columns brought to life and then skewered, scoffed at, debated, and given the full weight of Vine and Hitchens impenetrable gaze. Though an accord might not always be reached, it’s the journey that matters.
Whether it’s the tech bros gone rogue – Meta tearing up its own rule book on fact checking, Musk attempting to influence governmental policy, or the knotty subject on society’s ever-increasing reliance on anti-depressants to treat what might just be the modern malaise and not depression at all. Or, evil, nature or nurture? Does evil actually exist or is it an idea that hangs over us, or do we just sometime embody it and the actions themselves are evil, not the individual? All this and more are to be pored over, one towering topic each week discussed with humour, insight, and real understanding.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
But could someone tell Sarah Vine that the BBC can’t just sell iPlayer round the world like Netflix due to significant complexities around rights restrictions. People at the BBC aren’t so stupid that they’ve just never thought of that….
2025-10-16
Peter Hitchens
Peter Hitchens legend. Doesn’t give a fig, wish there were more like him. Keep saying what is right Peter!
2025-06-20
Best podcast out there
Centre left (ish) listener here. This podcast is wonderful. Funny, honest and witty - even when I disagree with Peter or Sarah, still love hearing their opinions and thoughts. Please make it 1 hour long. X x x
2025-06-18
Super fun
So entertaining, frequently intellectually fresh with many unique insights / scoops! Thanks
2025-05-03
A must listen every week! Their understated comedy stands out in the current podcast climate.
A must listen every week!
(And a refuge of sanity for many - of that I’m positive):
2025-04-10
So good!
Fantastic podcast. I know some think Hitchens is arrogant or out of touch but he is unquestionably far more educated and wiser than most journalists or politicians today. Most importantly, he thinks for himself and if perhaps not always entirely right, that’s certainly a respectable quality.
2025-04-02
Fantastic podcast
A great podcast. Just wish it was longer!
2025-04-01
Endlessly fascinating
A splendid podcast full of pomp and pomposity. However when they denigrate various food types for example I only wish they would discuss what they do in fact eat and what their favourite meals etc are. I would imagine Peter Hitchens has never eaten tomato sauce, a fruit smoothie or had a milkshake in his whole life but that’s possibly an inaccurate profile based on my perception!
2025-03-22
Doesnt work anymore
I used to enjoy this in Reaction mode but unsubscribed to the relaunch. Hitchens doesnt have the voice for podcasts and is too set in his opinions for it to be a lively discussion.
2025-03-14
Tiresome analysis light locating
I recently listened to Hitchens talk to Aaron Bastani and thought he gave a very good account of himself. I’m always looking to challenge my own biases to improve my understanding of the world & had had this recommended so dove in enthusiastically. I’m afraid my opinion has reverted back to my previous one, which is that Hitchens is a tiresome blowhard with an unrealistically high estimation of his own intelligence. This
is something quite natural with older journalists - particularly those surrounded by sycophants desperate to tell them how insightful they are, something I’m afraid Sarah Vine seems desperate to do. Hitchens is this free to weave elaborate (but stupid) theories presented like “eg if America lost the Cold War they would have lost California to Mexico” - all plausibly argued but also empty. A lot of his schtick is saying how stupid everyone is, except him of course, a classic guru technique to make you feel you, the listener, are the elect so able to see deeper. It’s a swindle frankly. I think this would work much better if he had an interlocutor who would push back at all but we all know he storms out of interviews when this happens (Cosmic Skeptic) so I guess that’s not an available option.
One final aside, I found the anecdote about how Hitchens used to avoid trouble when he frequented “public houses” very revealing. “Don’t provoke people” was the upshot. This betrays a level of abject physical cowardice that probably explains why he doesn’t go to pubs anymore, but hasn’t given him the insight that maybe one should stand up to bullies.
2025-03-12
Unlistenable
Hitchens is interesting but he continually talks over Sarah Vine ignoring every cue that it’s her turn to speak. This makes the podcast impossible to listen to.
2025-03-06
Loathsome
Is this satire? On what planet would anyone want to listen to this pair?
2024-09-05
Just discovered this fabulous pod
Sarah & Andrew are terrific together and say things as they are, no spin
2024-07-03
Much preferred Sarah Vine’s female half hour
I can’t quite take to this one. I much preferred Sarah and Imogen. Now that was a classy duo.
2024-06-30
Brilliant
Funny, poignant and relevant - love it.have downloaded several for those ‘spare moment’ Victoria Scarborough
2024-06-07
Love these two
I have only just started listening to this podcast and I love it. Short and to the point. Very easy listening.