After being left destroyed by the chaos that had followed Jim and his alcoholic alter ego Jack Devlin, Tin Star Season 2 picks up with the unlikely hero cut off in the remote Rockies wilderness with his grieving and shell-shocked family struggling to come to terms with their ordeal. Seeking refuge from her own parents, Anna is taken in by the God-fearing Nickel family, and hidden with the Ammonites - a religious community close to Little Big Bear. However, the peaceful prairie family are harboring secrets of its own and it's not long before Anna is forced to seek her father's help, as an altogether more hellish threat emerges. If Jim is to find a way to save his family, atone for his sins he must form an uneasy alliance in the battle for forgiveness.